Being a Beautiful Answer

“Always the beautiful answer who asks a more beautiful question.” – E. E. Cummings

This quote from E. E. Cummings is one of my favorites.  E. E. Cummings was a master of using the “wrong” parts of speech in both his poems and prose.  He often used nouns as verbs, verbs as nouns, adverbs as nouns, etc.  His punctuation at times seemed random, but often in the midst of reading one of his poems suddenly it becomes clear why he used a certain piece of punctuation in his “incorrect” way.

If you’ve never read the quote before, stop and read it again, and answer this question:

Who is the “who” referred to in the quote?

The “who” is “the beautiful answer”, right? — thus this quote is saying that the person who asks a beautiful question somehow is or becomes the beautiful answer.  The beautiful answer is a person, not an idea, a plan, a concept, or a strategy.  My big search in the larger community of faith today is not for those who are offering all the answers, not for those who have the most powerful strategies or ideas, but for those who are asking beautiful questions.

By “beautiful question” I wish to make it clear that I don’t mean using beautiful or flowery language in the formation of the question (and judging by E. E. Cummings poems, I don’t think that’s what he meant either).  Rather “beautiful” here means something that deeply resonates and touches the center of human existence.  For instance, when I see a homeless person begging on the street, his very existence can be a beautiful question I ask of myself or God or both.  If I do not ask the question, I never materialize as the beautiful answer.

The beautiful questions are the hard questions that many are afraid to ask.  They are the questions for which many are ready with pat answers, but the really beautiful questions do not have easy answers.  Instead, the answers often lead us to other hard questions.  For instance, at times when I have experienced the greatest and most profound suffering, those who comforted me the most were not those who quoted scriptures to me, or said “read your Bible more” or “pray more” or “Just trust God”, but rather those who let my hard question ring in the air unanswered, and even entered the question with me, and let themselves feel the full weight of what the question was asking.  In this way, they themselves became a beautiful answer for me that somehow enabled me to make sense of my pain, perhaps not intellectually, but in my depths.

Another example?  The book of Job in the Bible is God’s answer to Job’s profound and very beautiful question: “Why am I suffering?”  But what is the Book of Job but 42 chapters of questions?  Does God ever answer Job’s question?  I believe He does, but not with the pat answers that Job’s friends had offered.  Instead God answers Job’s questions with questions.  And the result is some of the most profoundly beautiful passages in the entire Bible.

Many of us, sincere and well-meaning, want to be the beautiful answer, but are we willing to ask beautiful questions?  Are we willing to ask the questions that are resonating with the world around us?  Are we willing to let the beggar, the hungry, the homeless be the question we ask ourselves?

Note 1/16/2015: For more information on the source of this e.e. cummings quote see my post: Beautiful Answer Quote.  There are also comments below about the the source of the quote that are not in the above-linked post.  This post was not meant to be about cummings, but about the concept in the quote and what it means in my own life, but I do welcome comments about cummings as well.

Advertisements

4 responses to “Being a Beautiful Answer

  1. Good thoughts. I’ll be digesting this for a time.

  2. Pingback: Beautiful Answer Quote « Alternative Church

  3. The quote doesn’t come from a cummings poem. It is from the “Introduction” he wrote to “Collected Poems.
    Thom Mayer, MD
    Medical Director
    NFL Players Association

  4. Thanks Thom! You are 100% correct! I tell where it is from in this post:
    https://beautifulquestion.com/2008/10/17/beautiful-answer-quote/

    I don’t know if you meant that I claimed it was a poem. I didn’t, but I didn’t say it wasn’t a poem and I did talk about Cummings writing poems, so for clarity I’ll put a note at the end.

    Your comment brings up a couple points about this quote that are somewhat unrelated to this specific post, and not really an answer to you, but for anyone who might follow this comment thread who found it because of their interest in cummings not in my reflections.

    From a literary standpoint (a big portion of my Masters work included literary analysis and criticism, though not on e.e. Cummings or even English lit): Though I too usually describe this introduction as “prose,” in the study of literature there is a classification called a “prose poem.” I think this piece of prose is easily classifiable as a prose poem (see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prose_poetry). For any interested parties, if after reading the definition of prose poetry, you look at the link there for “parataxis” be sure to read the second paragraph that talks about the concept of parataxis in poetry.

    Finally, also for people interested in the literature, after disclosing my study of literature, a couple disclaimers: First, I’m not a literary critic now nor am I an academic in literary studies, but I do use skills I learned there for my own pleasure, and one day may do more seriously again. Second, this blog post is not meant to be literary criticism but to explain the title of my blog. I used to call it something else, and at the time I changed the name was explaining what that name meant to me.” There is a tiny bit of literary analysis in the first portion of the post, but I’m only using that to jump off into talking about my own thoughts about what that concept means to me in my life, not what I think e.e. cummings thoughts were (though I think the general concept I put forth is a very decent interpretation, especially based on reading the entire introduction, which I highly recommend).

    That’s all. I really didn’t mean for my reply to be this long. It only is because I love literature, I love this quote, and I love the introduction that it came from.

    By the way, I’ve loved e.e. since I was a child because my Dad loved him and read aloud some of his poems to me. I began reading him for myself as a teen, and now will only say I’ve loved him for some decades (no exact math, haha, but it’s been a while). I still sometimes suddenly “get” a poem that I never understood before. He was not just a rule-breaker, he was very clever and profound and very, very very often (maybe always I don’t know) broke rules for a premeditated reason. Maybe some of his poems had no meaning (some argue that some didn’t). I will only say I still sometimes suddenly make sense of what I previously thought was nonsense. This blog is not about CummingS, but if anyone wants to chat about him or talk about what he’s meant to them, I’d welcome it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s